"Selection of carvings from |
Back when all life was single-celled, a "critter" now known as mitochondria invaded our cell walls, establishing a symbiotic relationship. We are the host. And, mitochondria provide energy to our cells. Lo these eons later, the mitochondria are still there. An offshoot of this relationship is that we can trace our direct descent from Mitochondrial Eve, the first Homo Sapien female whose descendants still survive, down through the maternal line using mtDNA.
What does DNA analysis tell us? DNA is the definitive answer for personal genealogical research. But, it also tells the history of the migration of entire peoples. National Geographic's Genographic Project is an effort to map the migrations of ethnic groups through man's pre-history. [Research]
In the last decade, great strides have been made identifying new SNPs down the human genome. And, anthropologists have been able to match these mutations to specific places on the timeline of human history. With this information, we can affix our forefathers (foremothers?) to specific times and places in the migration of modern man.1. Exogamy: the Enemy of mtDNA Reseach
group.Having participated in Genetic Genealogy for years, I thought I could duplicate my yDNA research and apply those functions and lessons-learned to my new mtDNA test. Well, no. To me, the descent of man through the maternal line does not appear to be straightforward. After serious consideration, I am beginning to understand why.
Over the eons, Homo Sapiens have migrated in groups. My yDNA research indicates that males from related families, and thus of the same haplogroup, were the core of their local group. And, those males had progeny with females who were found in the immediate locale. Exogamy is defined as the social norm of marrying outside one's social group. Thus, the new wives were acquired from their group and added to the patrilocal
Consider this scenario:
-Appropriately for genetic diversity and thus genetic success, young males search for partners from the females at the new location who potentially are of a different branch of Haplogroup H or even from a completely different mtDNA Haplogroup altogether.-A family group migrates from Point A to Point B. The males are predominantly yDNA Haplogroup R. The females are predominantly mtDNA Haplogroup H.
Dispersion of female lineages amongst the many disparate male populations across Eurasia points to the absence of large populations of genetically homogeneous females who occupied a specific location at a specific time. But, was there a core female population--anthropologists describe mother/ daughter groups--who migrated together and comprised a significant percentage of their migratory culture?
I found evidence of these matrilineal clusters where ancient populations of the Late Neolithic and Bronze Age were tested for mtDNA:
MtDNA
frequencies based on
|
|
Y-DNA frequencies based on
|
||||||
Region/ Haplogroup |
HV |
H |
|
Region/ Haplogroup |
R1a |
R1b |
||
Yamna (n=44) | 3300 - 2600 BCE | 0 | 22.5 | Yamna (n=12) | 3300 - 2600 BCE | 0 | 91.5 | |
Corded Ware (n=71) | 3000 - 2350 BCE | 0 | 21.0 | Corded Ware (n=17) | 3000 - 2350 BCE | 70.5 | 11.5 | |
German Bell Beaker/ Proto-Unetica (n=47) |
3000 - 2300 BCE | 2 | 42.5 | Czech & German Bell Beaker/ Proto-Unetica (n=68) |
3000 - 2300 BCE | 0 | 93.5 | |
Dutch, French & Swiss Bell Beaker (n=14) |
3000 - 2300 BCE | 0 | 100 | |||||
Iberian Bell Beaker (n=17) | 2900 - 2200 BCE | 0 | 35.0 | |||||
British Bell Beaker & EBA (n=47) | 2800 - 1800 BCE | 1.4 | 22.9 | British Bell Beaker (n=21) | 2800 - 1800 BCE | 0 | 95.0 | |
Unetica (n=87) | 2300 - 1600 BCE | 2.5 | 20.5 | |||||
Fatyanovo (n=40) | 2900 - 2050 BCE | 0 | 20.0 | Fatyanovo (n=14) | 2900 - 2050 BCE | 100 | 0 | |
Catacomb (n=28) | 2500 - 1950 BCE | 0 | 25.0 | |||||
Poltavka/ Sintashta (n=10) | 2050 - 1750 BCE | 0 | 20.0 | Sintashta (n=2) | 2050 - 1750 BCE | 100 | 0 | |
Andronovo (n=30) | 2000 - 1450 BCE | 3.5 | 10.0 | Andronovo & Karasuk (n=7) | 2000 - 1450 BCE | 75.1 | 0 | |
Srubna (n=14) | 1850 - 1450 BCE | 0 | 35.5 | Srubna (n=7) | 1850 - 1450 BCE | 100 | 0 | |
Exogamy in action: Although some clades of
mtDNA Haplogroup H interbred with Yamna R1b and Corded Ware R1a, the
majority of the women carrying this haplogroup went elsewhere. I
postulate that they migrated west from Anatolia to Iberia.
Information gleamed from: |
||||||||
Genetic History of the Iberian Peninsula |
||||||||
Region |
Sample Size |
V | H | Region | Sample Size | R1a | R1b | |
North of the Ebro | ||||||||
Galicia | 88 | 0% | 57% | |||||
Asturias | 20 | 0% | 50% | |||||
Cantabrian Coast | 1520 | 1% | 52% | Cantabria | 70 | 4% | 58% | |
Basques | 116 | 0% | 87% | |||||
Mediterranean Coast | 1058 | 2% | 37% | Catalonia | 80 | 0% | 81% | |
South of the Ebro | ||||||||
Leon | 60 | 7% | 62% | |||||
Castile NW | 100 | 2% | 60% | |||||
Iberian Plateau | 1318 | 2% | 32% | Castile NE | 31 | 0% | 77% | |
Aragon | 34 | 3% | 56% | |||||
Information gleamed from: "Genetic History of the Iberian Peninsula" <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_history_of_the_Iberian_Peninsula> 24 July 2022. |
2. Archaeological Periods
We measure mankind's progress toward our modern world and divide his achievements into periods by his manufacture and use of tools and the development of technology. These Archaeological Periods are given names for the materials from which those tools were made: the Stone Age, the Bronze Age, the Iron Age, etc. And, the dates for the many periods of man's development vary depending on where man lived in the ancient world.
Archaeological Periods by Continent and Region: Near East |
||
Paleolithic | Lower Paleolithic |
2,600,000 – 300,000 BCE
|
Middle Paleolithic |
300,000 – 40,000 BCE
|
|
Upper Paleolithic |
40,000 – 19,000 BCE
|
|
Mesolithic | Stage 1 |
18,800 – 12,150 BCE |
Stage 2 |
11,140 – 9,500 BCE
|
|
Neolithic | Early Neolithic |
10,000 – 8,500 BCE |
Middle Neolithic |
8,500 – 6,500 BCE |
|
Late Neolithic |
6,500 – 4,500 BCE |
|
Copper/ Eneolithic Age |
4,500 – 3,300 BCE
|
|
Bronze Age |
3,300 – 1,200 BCE
|
|
Archaeological Periods by Continent and Region: Western Europe |
||
Iron Age |
1,100 – 1 CE |
|
Roman |
1 – 400 CE |
|
Early medieval period |
400 – 800 CE |
|
Medieval period |
800 – 1,500 CE |
|
Post-medieval period |
1,500 – 1,800 CE |
|
Industrial/Modern |
1,800 CE to present |
|
"List of Archeological Periods," Wikipedia <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_archaeological_periods> 10 June 2015. |
3. Locating pre-historic Man: The Genographic Project
The Genographic Project was created by the National Geographic Society as "an ambitious attempt to answer fundamental questions about where we originated and how we came to populate the Earth."
I became aware of the Genographic Project in about 2006 after I submitted my first yDNA test. FTDNA provided a link where you could contribute your test results to the Genographic Project for a minimal contribution ($25).
When humans first ventured out of Africa some 60,000 years ago, they left genetic footprints still visible today. By mapping the appearance and frequency of genetic markers in modern peoples, we create a picture of when and where ancient humans moved around the world. These great migrations eventually led the descendants of a small group of Africans to occupy even the farthest reaches of the Earth.
"The Human Journey," National Geographic Genographic Project <https://genographic.nationalgeographic.com/human-journey/> 12 July 2015.
4. The Peopling of Western Europe
The following excerpt provides a concise history of the peopling of Western Europe:
"The settlement history of Europe has been punctuated by several major episodes
over the past 50,000 years. . ."
a. "These include the first arrival of modern
humans from Africa during the Upper Paleolithic. . ." b. "the Late Glacial
repeopling of Europe from southern refugia. . ." c. -"the Postglacial recolonization
of deserted areas after the end of the Younger Dryas. . ." d. "the farming-related
population expansion of Near Easterners into Europe during the Neolithic.
. ." e. "and the small-scale migrations along continent-wide economic exchange
networks beginning from the Copper Age onward." f. "Furthermore, a number of Urheimat hypotheses suggest the proto-Indo-European culture [male Haplogroup R1b] completed its expansion to Europe between the fifth and first millennia BCE, leaving the Basque language the only remnant of the antedating [original/ autochthonous] culture in Western Europe. The way in which these events have left their genetic footprints on the current European gene pool has been the focus of intense genetic research over the last decades." The asterisk [*] indicates my notes. |
5. Phylogeny of mtDNA Haplogroup H
The mtDNA sequence for my Mom's Wilkinson/ Case family has been traced down to Haplogroup H1bb. And, the evolution of H1bb is cited at FTDNA..
|
mt Haplogroup |
Timeframe |
Phylogenetic branch with SNPs: |
1 |
L
mtDNA Eve |
300,000 BCE | Phylogenetic root for
mitochondrial DNA of homo sapiens with C allele at hg19:15443. Neanderthal and Denisovan samples have T allele at this position. Includes differences from hg38 reference sequence which could be expressed as: A73G, T152C, T195C, A750G, A8860G, A10398G, T10873C, C12705T, A13105G, G16129A, T16189C, C16223T, C16278T. |
2 |
L1'2'3'4'5'6'7 Drop L0 |
200,000 BCE | A11914G , C10915T, C146T, C182T, G13276A, G16230A, T10664C, T4312C. |
3 | L2'3'4'6 Drop L1'5 |
A10688G, A16129G, A247G, A825t, C10810T, C16189T, C195T, G13105A, G15301A, T13506C, T16187C, T8655C. | |
4 | L3'4'6 Drop L2 |
A7521G, G4104A. | |
5 |
L3'4 Drop L6 |
T13650C, T16278C, T182C!, T3594C, T7256C | |
6 | L3 Drop L4 |
84,000 BCE | A1018G, A769G, C16311T. |
7 | N Drop M |
70.000 BCE | A15301G!, C10873T, C9540T, G10398A, G8701A. |
8 | R Drop O, A, S, I, W, X, Y |
65,000 BCE | T12705C, T16223C. |
9 | R0 Drop B, F, JT, P, U |
c. 30,000 BCE | A11719G, G73A. |
10 | HV Drop R0 |
>24,000 BCE | T14766C. Britain's DNA labeled this branch: Sheban. |
11 | H Drop V |
20,000 BCE | G2706A, T7028C. Britain's DNA labeled this branch: Pioneers. |
12 | H1 | 7,000 BCE | G3010A. Britain's DNA labeled this branch: Western Refuges. |
H1-T152C! "Mitochondrial DNA: Part 2," DNA eXplained <https://dna-explained.com/2019/05/23/mitochondrial-dna-part-2> 22 July 2022. |
|||
13 | H1bb | 4,000 BCE | T11864C |
Information gleamed from "Ancestral DNA Marker Pedigree Display" <https://www.genetichomeland.com/welcome/dnapedigree.asp> 11 July 2022. |
6. Synthesis
-Take the evolutionary history of a genetic marker (H1bb) from ISOGG.
-Overlay the archaeological time periods.
-Overlay the physical locations determined by the Genographic Project.
-And, we begin to see the migration history of our ancient ancestors.
Haplogroup |
When |
Where |
Root L Mitochondrial Eve | 400,000 BCE | Middle Paleolithic Period. Modern man emerges in Central Africa. This early date is based on the finds at Jebel Irhoud (modern Morocco) which date to 315,000 ka. How long did it take modern man to migrate through the Sahara to the Atlantic coast of northwest Africa? The original line of Homo Sapiens were Rh Negative. Rh Positive is the mutation. |
L1-6 | 170,000 BCE | Lived in Central Africa. |
L3 | 84,000 BCE | Out of Africa dispersion. Migrated north toward the Red Sea. Note: All non sub-Saharan Africans, worldwide, descend from L3. |
N | 70,000 BCE | Migrated north through the Red Sea Rift to the Levant then further north into Anatolia. |
R | 65,000 BCE | Possibly emerged in Anatolia. From there, the people began to disperse into the Caucasus and north to the Pontic Steppe. |
R0 (zero) | c. 30,000 BCE | Upper Paleolithic Period Found en route to the Pontic Steppe among the Eneolithic Trypillia Culture vic modern Moldova.. |
HV | >24,000 BCE | Exogamy* in action: Also emerged in Anatolia. Migrated west towards Iberia. Some Haplogroup H may have dropped off and migrated northwest into Central Europe and migrated north over the Caucasus to the Pontic Steppe. |
H | 20,000 BCE | Mesolithic Period Survived the Last Glacial Maximum in the Refugium** in the Franco-Cantabrian Region of southern France and northwestern Iberia. |
H1 | 15,000 BCE | Late Mesolithic Period/ Neolithic Period Dispersed northeast into central France. |
H1bb | 4,000 BCE | Dispersed throughout central Europe. |
yDNA
R1b1a1a2a1a2a1b/ |
after |
Bronze Age |
*Exogamy
is defined as the social norm of marrying outside one's social group.
**A refugium is a protected place of refuge, perhaps a sheltered valley where early man survived the hardships of the last Ice Age. Well researched refugia are the Dordogne Valley of western France which wends east to the Vezere and the cave paintings at Lascaux and the Garonne Valley of south central France which wends south to the Pyrenees and northern Spain. x Researh Note: These dates are toward the older end of the spectrum. With the crossing of Homo Sapiens to Australia being backdated from 40,000 BCE to 65,000 BCE, early man would have had to have ventured out of Africa earlier rather than later. And thus, the earlier dates. |
7. Developing a History
A Pre-History of mtDNA Haplogroup H
|
|
Root L (mt Eve) |
|
The map is not intended to show the exact route taken by modern man from Africa to Iberia. Instead, it is a depiction of individual migration stages. |
|
1. mtDNA L: As previously stated, the progress of modern man
toward our modern world is measured
by his manufacture and use of tools and
the development of technology and is characterized by the materials
he used. Anthropologists posit that modern man, Homo Sapiens, emerged in Africa in about
400,000 BCE. Thus, the emergence of Anatomically Modern Humans [AMH]
marks the beginning of the Middle Paleolithic Period with the
appearance of their new technologies.
The female ancestor of all people living today is called Mitochondrial Eve. Mitochondrial Eve may have originated in the vicinity of Lake Turkana in the Kenyan Rift Valley on the border of modern Ethiopia. |
|
2. Haplogroup L3: Out of Africa Dispersion c. 84,000 BCE Modern human's first family, Haplogroup L, began mutating back when our forefathers were still in Africa. Haplogroup L0 remained in Central Africa. Our family migrated up the valleys of the East African Rift along the streams and marshes until they encountered the White Nile on the west or the Afar Triangle to the east.
These people and this location are very important; as all modern non sub-Saharan Africans descend from L3. Thus the descendants of these people would have migrated northeast to cross the Red Sea and go on to populate Asia and continue north up the Nile or the Red Sea Rift to populate North Africa, the Levant, the Central Asian Steppe, the Pontic Steppe, and eventually Europe. Some paleontologists postulate that ancient man sojourned in the lands northwest of Lake Turkana. From there, they would have continued on northward until they encountered the White Nile, eventually migrating north along the river bed toward the Mediterranean. But, I believe that there was an ancient route where very ancient man migrated back and forth along the Red Sea Rift and the Dead Sea Rift to the Levant and even the Balkans and then back.
These return migrations would explain how modern man encountered and "admixed" with Neanderthals c. 100,000 BCE. "Fossil DNA Reveals New Twists in Modern Human Origins" <https://www.quantamagazine.org/fossil-dna-reveals-new-twists-in-modern-human-origins> 24 July 2022. |
|
3.
Haplogroup
N:
c. 70,000 BCE. Originated in Africa/
Our family continued migrating north along the Red Sea Rift to the Dead Sea Rift and then finally uphill into the Levant. Continuing along the Dead Sea Rift, they would have reached the East Anatolian Fault which would have taken them northeast into Anatolia and along the route to the Caucasus. Recent mtDNA testing indicates that Haplogroup N also migrated west across North Africa and crossed into Europe via the Gibraltar Strait. And, Haplogroup N was the predominant female lineage of Cro Magnon/ Aurignacian Culture.
|
|
4. Haplogroup R & R0: c. 65000 - 30,000 BCE Haplogroup R may have emerged in Anatolia c. 65,000 BCE. From there, the people began to disperse into the Caucasus and north to the Pontic Steppe. Haplogroup R0 is found west of the Black Sea en route to the Pontic Steppe among the Eneolithic Trypillia Culture (5500 - 2750 BCE). |
|
7. Haplogroup HV:. >24,000 BCE Exogamy in action, encore. Our people emerged in Anatolia and dispersed from there.
Women from Haplogroup HV who do not have further mutations are found among the Andronovo Culture where they would have migrated north through the Caucasus and intermarried with the Pastorialists on the Pontic Steppe, among the Bell Beaker and Unetice Cultures of Central Europe where they would have migrated northwest, up the Danube Valley into Central Europe, and west along the Mediterranean to the Franco-Cantabrian Region of Southern Gaul/ Northern Iberia. Our people would have arrived in the Franco Cantabrian Refugium during the Last Glacial Maximum and would have survived until the end of the Ice Age in the valleys and caves just north and south of the Pyrenees.
|
|
8. Haplogroup H: c. 20,000 BCE Our people arrived in the Franco-Cantabrian Region of Iberia before the Last Glacial Maximum. Sometime around 20,000 BCE, Haplogroup H emerged. Our people are not the Cro Magnon; as mtDNA analysis proves that those people were Haplogroup N, our distant cousins. But, our Haplogroup H people were their replacements.
|
|
9. Haplogroup
H1: c. 15,000 BCE
Haplogroup H1 emerged in the area of the Franco-Cantabrian Refugium at the end of the last Ice Age. They are credited with expanding out into Central Europe where they would have interbred with the incoming Farmers during the Neolithic and then the Pastorialists from the Pontic Steppe at the beginning of the Bronze Age.
|
|
11. Haplogroup H1bb: c. 4,000 BCE? A definite date for the emergence of H1bb has yet to be determined. From the Refugium north and south of the Pyrenees, our people could have migrated into Central Europe. Some stayed in Iberia. Either case, they would have encountered the newly arrived yDNA Haplogroup R1b Celts migrating south out of Gaul and into Iberia. |
8. The First Meeting
My father was R-DF27 and my mother was mtH1bb; as proven by yDNA and mtDNA. And, they met in Louisiana. But, that wasn't the first meeting of those lineages:
At the end of the Neolithic c. 4,000 BCE, female Haplogroup H1bb was settled on the northwest of the Iberian Peninsula and north of the Pyrenees in southern Gaul. They and their cousins had began expanding outward to repopulate Central Europe after the last Ice Age. By around 2,250 BCE, male Haplogroup R-DF27 was migrating south out of Gaul toward Iberia. Without a doubt, the two groups met. But as yet, I do not have proof that my parents were genetically related.
R1b1a1a2a1a2a1b [DF27/S250]:
When R-DF27 reached southern Gaul, they encountered and intermixed with the local females, the ancestors of my Mother's family.. Migrating c. 24,000 BCE west from Anatolia to Iberia, the descendants of female Haplogroups HV, H, & H1 had been in Iberia over 20,000 years before the arrival of male R-DF27. These female descendants of Haplogroup H then followed their Celtic men during the subsequent migrations up until our modern time. The Iberian Celts continued their migration southwest into the Douro Valley and then south to the region of Beira Alta and its capitol, Guarda, in what is now Portugal. Here, the Lusitanians settled. They spoke the proto-Celtic Lusitanian language. The Gaelic Celts continued their migration, this time north to the northwest coast of the Iberian Peninsula and the regions of Gallaecia and Asturias in what is now Spain. They spoke q-Celt/ Goidelic/ Gaelic. The Bronze Age did not appear in Iberia until 1800 BCE, and was mostly confined to the cultures of El Argar and Los Millares in south-east Spain, with sporadic sites showing up in Castile by 1700 BCE and in Extremadura and southern Portugal by 1500 BCE. These Early Bronze Age sites typically did not have more than some bronze daggers or axes and cannot be considered proper Bronze Age societies, but rather Copper Age societies with occasional bronze artefacts (perhaps imported). These cultures might have been founded by small groups of R1b adventurers looking for easy conquests in parts of Europe that did not yet have bronze weapons. They would have become a small ruling elite, would have had children with local women, and within a few generations their Indo-European language would have been lost, absorbed by the indigenous languages. Our people are the Milesians of Irish Mythology. They settled in Gallaecia on the northwest coast of the Iberian Peninsula where they became a trading nation along the Atlantic coast. Our people eventually worked their way up the coast of the Celtic Sea in their little round boats, most probably landing in Armorica (Brittany, France). From Armorica, they crossed the Irish Sea to Ireland.
According to Lebor Gabála Érenn, the "Book of the Taking of Ireland," in about 1,000 BCE, the Milesians sailed across the Celtic Sea and became the Over Kings of Ireland. Having populated Ireland, their descendants, the Scoti, went on to populate Scotland and Wales. The descendants of DF27 (post 1,000 BCE) who remained in Iberia spoke Gallaecian. Their cousins, the Celtiberians of central Spain, were a conglomeration of original Celt and autochthonous Iberians and spoke, not a different dialect, but a different q-Celt language.
|
9. Conclusions
Through the appearance of individual markers on the human genome, our ancestor's path out of Africa into Southwest Asia and then to Western Europe has been proven. It's actually a simple process: a) match the locations of the donors to the SNP markers found b) play connect the dots. With the addition of dates from ancient archaeological periods and mtDNA evidence from the folks who came before us, we can approximate where our ancestors were during specific times along the timeline of human history.
Tracing the evolution of mtDNA Haplogroup H and our subclade H1bb, we learn that we descend from a maternal line who migrated to Iberia in the Mesolithic Period and survived the Last Glacial Maximum in the Franco-Cantabrian Refugium. And as the ice sheets retreated, we expanded outward to help populate Neolithic and Bronze Age Europe. Today, our cousins along the maternal Haplogroup H lineage constitute the majority of people in Western Europe.